Customer Rating:  
Summary: Excellent movie about an interesting true story.
Comment: This is a pretty interesting movie. It is based on a true story. At times, especially at the beginning, it seems to jump quickly over events. It takes a little to get into the flow of the movie and feel comfortable with who the characters are. The end of the movie is a bit abrupt also. You aren't quite sure what happened to some of the main characters between the last days of the war and the ending where the main character is in a Casino in Monaco. In spite of these drawbacks, this is an interesting movie that makes you want to go out and learn more about the events it was based on.
Customer Rating:
Summary: A Compelling Story, Strangely Told
Comment: The German-Austrian film The Counterfeiters is based on a remarkable true story. Late in World War Two the Nazis rounded up Jews who had been confined in various concentration camps and set up a large counterfeiting operation designed to undermine the British and U.S. economies. The Nazis found some 150 Jews with the necessary skills and put them together in a special section within the Sachsenhausen concentration camp, providing the latest money-making equipment, giving them plenty of food and comfortable accommodations. But the counterfeiters were constantly pressured to produce (at pain of death) and there were sadistic S.S. guards who cruelly reminded the counterfeiters that they were still in Hell.
Just outside the counterfeiters' quarters other prisoners were brutalized by the Nazis. In one incident, a group of the counterfeiters can hear a guard insulting a man as he executes him. The bullets fly through the very wooden wall next to which they are standing.
It's an important and compelling story. But much of the film was shot with a hand-held that often awkwardly jumps from actor to actor in prolonged scenes. In one of the DVD special features writer-director Stefan Ruzowitzky asserted that he was trying to create a documentary effect. I think he failed at this. It all comes off as too contrived.
The main character is Saloman "Sally" Sorowitsch, portrayed very energetically by Karl Markovics. Sally is a very clever, tough, wily man who jerkily moves about like a bantam rooster surrounded by mean foxes. His eyes dart from tormentor to tormentor. Too much eye-darting, if such a thing is possible. Markovics likes to strike a pose, as do the other key players, both victims and tormentors. They are quite good at striking poses, but enough is enough.
I recommend the audio commentary by Ruzowitzky. He addresses some of the things I wondered about, like the sometimes bizarre soundtrack. The interview given by Adolf Burger is very touching. Now in his nineties, he is a survivor of the counterfeiters. Burger was a consultant on the film. He has devoted decades of his life to keeping the memory of the Holocaust and the counterfeiting operation alive.
Although this film received the 2007 Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film, I would not rate it so highly. It just did not seem "genuine," somewhat like a good counterfeit.
Customer Rating:
Summary: an amazing more or less true story
Comment: Until watching this movie, I had no idea that the largest counterfeiting operation of all time was carried out by prisoners in a Nazi concentration camp. They were assigned to forge pounds and dollars, in order to undermine the Allied economy and finance the Nazi war effort. They ended up printing over 100 million pounds sterling, which even the Bank of England could not distinguish from the genuine article. On the other hand, as a result of stalling tactics, they didn't crack the dollar until the war was almost over and it no longer made any difference.
This movie is a fictionalized version of this story. Prisoners with relevant skills are brought in to a special, top-secret area in a concentration camp, where in contrast to the appalling conditions elsewhere, they are provided with sufficient food, decent beds, time for breaks, etc. But if they don't produce results, they will be shot. Sorowich, a master counterfeiter, is brought in to take charge of the counterfeiting operation. Burger, one of the other workers on the operation, wants to sabotage the operation, so as to hamper the Nazi war effort. This view is not popular among the other workers, who do not feel like dying for this cause, just so that other workers can be brought in to do the job for them. Much of the movie is a dramatization of this moral argument. The end result is to delay the production of the dollar just enough. The protagonist is Sorowich, who initially just wants to save his skin, and also has a personal longing to crack the dollar, but eventually sort of comes around to the other point of view.
The movie is very well done. The acting is excellent, especially the actors who play Sorowich, and Herzog, the boss of the concentration camp. One is really immersed in the concentration camp, which is quite scary, although not nearly as gruesome as it could be since we are in the elite section.
The bonus features are worth watching and tell more about the true story on which the movie is based. For example, in reality, only two people knew about the sabotage, unlike in the movie where for dramatic purposes lots of people knew about it so that they could argue about it on screen.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Riveting movie, but...........................
Comment: This was a riveting movie. The will to live and survive cast the tormnetors and the tormented in the same boat.
But the fragmented English subtiles spoils. Whoever did them did not know Englsh or was a sleep at the wheel. Many portions are without substitles. When they do appear, they are in bits and pieces, making them meaningless, ruining the enjoyment of the film.
Sellers should check out the DVD instead of making customers the quailty controllers.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Great Germanic Opus
Comment: The Counterfeiters is one very good film. It's even better when one considers it is based on a true event within Nazi Germany! Jewish counterfeiters and forgers who ran afoul of the law are in a prison camp and are recruited by the Third Reich to counterfeit American and British banknotes. How this is accomplished and why it ultimately fails is carried out in detail in this film.
The film is in German, with fairly large English sub-titles. Among the extras is a queston-and-answer period with the director, who speaks near-perfect English. There are few other extras. Beautifully photographed, it was the best foreign-language Oscar winner for 2007. Very highly recommended!
|
